Who do you think will be the bottom 3? Vote now in the tommybailey.com poll.
This was an interesting night. It wasn't boring, but it wasn't ecstatic either. Taylor stole the show tonight, but every contestant had at least one good tune to perform tonight. It gets tougher every week to guess on who will be asked by America to leave. We'll soon see tomorrow, but until then, you should vote in the tommybailey.com poll and let your voice be heard (you'vde been right every time).
Katherine McPhee:
- Against All Odds, pitchy, and boring.
- Black Horse and the Cherry Tree, was odd, but I liked it, I thought it was fun and creative, loved the intimate percussion.
Elliott Yamin: This guy can sing, but not as well tonight.
- On Broadway was done really well, was a little stale to me
- Home, there's no place like home, or is it there's no place for Home. Boring.
Paris Bennett: Overall, she did well, but I'm afraid not well enough. Even though I hate to say it (I think she has one of the best voices on the show) Paris didn't show us who she really is tonight, and she won't make it past this week.
- Kiss was okay, but not really a stellar moment
- I love Mary J. Blige, and Paris did a great job with her latest tune, but I'm not sure that those who don't know the song are going to like it.
Taylor Hicks: Great performances, both of them.
- Play That Funky Music was written for Taylor Hicks. The judges really rattled him on the first tune, but man, he was made for that song, and he executed it brilliantly. It may have been a little over the top towards the end, but Taylor is Taylor. One of my favorite performances this season.
- You have to hand it to Taylor, he found some way to get a 30 year old tune off a current top 10 list, brilliant. The Beatles tune Something was perfect.
Chris Daughtry:- Loved his first performance, Renegade, possibly the best of the night.
- I Dare You by Shinedown was terrible. It may have been okay live, but translated to television, it was a shouting match.
Remember to vote in the tommybailey.com poll.